運作方式
三藩市及加州 Ballot Backstory以七種語言說明每項提案的歷史、資金和支持者。以下說明這些頁面如何製作和核查。
我們發布甚麼
每項提案一頁:投贊成票和反對票的作用、提案為何現在出現在選票上、涉及的資金、由誰列入選票、誰背書、雙方各由誰出資,以及支持和反對的最有力論點。其中七項提案還附有過去決策的時間線,以及過往提案承諾與成果的紀錄。
每一頁如何撰寫
我們從原始資料出發:官方選民指南、主計長和立法分析師的財務分析、法律條文、競選財務申報以及已發布的背書。人工智能模型只根據這些資料起草每一頁,每一句都附有支持該句的來源連結。
自動核查
頁面上線前沒有任何人審閱或編輯。每個頁面都必須通過以下自動核查。最後一欄顯示有多少已發佈頁面通過了每項核查。
| 核查 | 結果 |
|---|---|
| 引用:由第二個模型確認每段引文都支持其所屬的句子。 | 175 個頁面通過 |
| 數字:由程式將每個數字與來源數據比對。 | 175 個頁面通過 |
| 引文:由程式確認每段引文都逐字出現在已保存的來源中。 | 175 個頁面通過 |
| 交叉核查:由另一家公司的人工智能模型重新核查各項陳述。 | 175 個頁面略過 |
| 中立性:由模型以進步派、溫和派和保守派讀者的角度閱讀,按中立準則為每份草稿評分。改寫後仍不合格的頁面只顯示官方文本。 | 175 個頁面通過 |
| 淺白語言:由模型檢查每個頁面是否容易閱讀。 | 175 個頁面通過 |
| 翻譯:由兩個模型各自翻譯,兩者意思不一致的部分會重新翻譯。 | — |
| 回譯:由另一個模型把譯文翻回英文,以找出意思上的改變。 | 150 個頁面通過 · 25 個頁面不適用 |
| 詞彙表:選舉用語必須與三藩市和加州的官方翻譯一致。 | 150 個頁面通過 · 25 個頁面不適用 |
| 中文用詞:簡體中文頁面會檢查中國大陸、台灣和香港的用詞差異。 | 25 個頁面通過 |
| 讀者:任何人都可以在任何部分、以任何語言報告錯誤。 | — |
我們使用哪些 AI 模型
每個頁面都由 Anthropic 的 AI 模型撰寫和核查。此表根據每個已發佈頁面所附的紀錄統計。
| 步驟 | 模型 | 頁數 |
|---|---|---|
| bloc_summary | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 175 |
| impact | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 175 |
| 撰寫初稿 | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 175 |
| 研究為甚麼現在會出現在選票上 | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 49 |
| 核查引用來源 | Claude Sonnet (Anthropic) | 175 |
| 中立性核查 | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 175 |
| 淺白語言核查 | Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 175 |
| 翻譯 | Claude Opus (Anthropic) | 150 |
| 翻譯 | Claude Sonnet (Anthropic) | 150 |
| 第二份獨立翻譯 | Claude Sonnet (Anthropic) | 150 |
| 比較兩份翻譯 | Claude Sonnet (Anthropic) | 150 |
| 回譯 | Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 150 |
本次選舉沒有進行由其他公司模型執行的交叉核查,因此上表顯示為略過。
我們如何保持中立
我們從不背書。我們以支持者的說法呈現雙方最有力的論點。贊成和反對所用的顏色不帶政黨或好壞含義,我們頁面上的兩個橢圓形都一直留空。
我們如何在聯盟光譜上定位提案
聯盟光譜由進步派聯盟延伸至溫和派聯盟。提案的位置只取決於我們追蹤的哪些團體背書或反對,以及雙方各由誰出資,並採用下方列出的團體分類。這不是我們對提案的意見。
州提案的量尺一端是加州民主黨及其盟友,另一端是加州共和黨及其盟友,例如 Howard Jarvis 納稅人協會。位置的判定方法相同:只看哪些被追蹤的團體為各方背書或出資。
資金數字的來源
三藩市的競選資金數據來自三藩市道德委員會在DataSF上的申報資料,每天更新。州提案的資金數據來自加州州務卿(Cal-Access)。每個資金數字都會顯示我們納入的最新申報日期。
我們如何計算費用例子
提案頁面上的費用例子(例如業主每年的稅單)由程式(ai/impact_costs.py)根據各頁所引用的稅率和金額計算。這些數字並非由人工智能模型撰寫或估算。每個例子都列明其假設,例如建築面積和評估價值,因此您自己的稅單會有所不同。
我們如何翻譯
頁面翻譯成中文(繁體和簡體)、西班牙文、菲律賓文、越南文和俄文。用語會與選務處的詞彙表核對,第三個模型會將譯文翻譯回英文以發現意思上的改變;凡三藩市或州政府發布選票問題的官方譯本,我們都會顯示該原文。俄文沒有官方譯本,因此俄文頁面必須達到最嚴格的一致性標準。
為何每一頁都標示由人工智能生成
這些頁面由人工智能模型撰寫和核查。我們在每一頁都加上標示,讓您隨時知道,並顯示每一頁最後一次核查的時間。
更正及錯誤報告
每個部分都有「報告錯誤」按鈕。每項更正都會連同日期和更改內容列在公開的更正紀錄中。
我們追蹤的團體及其分類方式
| 團體 | 類型 | 分類 | 原因 |
|---|---|---|---|
| San Francisco Democratic Party | party | 政黨 | sf axis +0.40 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.81 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| San Francisco Republican Party | party | 政黨 | sf axis +0.60 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors) |
| GrowSF | advocacy | 溫和派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's moderate end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis +0.56 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis +0.04 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| TogetherSF Action (now Blueprint SF) | advocacy | 溫和派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's moderate end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis +1.00 (computed from 6 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors) |
| San Francisco Chamber of Commerce | business | 溫和派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's moderate end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis +0.79 (computed from 7 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis +1.00 (computed from 5 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Abundant SF | advocacy | 溫和派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's moderate end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; No Nov 2026 positions could be read; the org has no effect on any score. |
| San Francisco League of Pissed Off Voters | advocacy | 進步派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's progressive end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis -0.85 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.86 (computed from 11 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club | democratic-club | 進步派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's progressive end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis -0.85 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.96 (computed from 12 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Democratic Socialists of America, San Francisco | advocacy | 進步派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's progressive end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| San Francisco Berniecrats | advocacy | 進步派名單 | Anchor for the sf scale's progressive end, as listed in PLAN.md §5; No Nov 2026 positions could be read; the org has no effect on any score. |
| San Francisco Labor Council | labor | 勞工 | sf axis -0.78 (computed from 3 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors) |
| SPUR | good-government | 其他團體 | sf axis +0.65 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -1.00 (computed from 10 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| League of Women Voters of San Francisco | good-government | 其他團體 | sf axis -0.85 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors) |
| YIMBY Action | advocacy | 其他團體 | sf axis +0.78 (computed from 6 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -1.00 (computed from 3 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| San Francisco Chronicle editorial board | newspaper | 其他團體 | No Nov 2026 positions could be read; the org has no effect on any score. |
| San Francisco Women's Political Committee | advocacy | 其他團體 | sf axis -0.60 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.89 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club | democratic-club | 其他團體 | sf axis +0.40 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.89 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Edwin M. Lee Asian Pacific Democratic Club | democratic-club | 其他團體 | sf axis +0.77 (computed from 8 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.12 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| San Francisco Green Party | party | 政黨 | sf axis -0.83 (computed from 7 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the moderate anchors, -1 = always with the progressive anchors); state axis -0.27 (computed from 13 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| SEIU Local 1021 | labor | 勞工 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| San Francisco Taxpayers Association | taxpayer | 其他團體 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| Sierra Club, San Francisco Bay Chapter | environmental | 其他團體 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| San Francisco Tenants Union | tenant-advocacy | 其他團體 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| United Educators of San Francisco | labor | 勞工 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| Coalition on Homelessness | advocacy | 其他團體 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| Small Business Forward | business | 商界 | sf axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| California Democratic Party | party | 政黨 | Anchor for the state scale's left end (the two major parties and the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn.); state axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| California Republican Party | party | 政黨 | Anchor for the state scale's right end (the two major parties and the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn.); state axis +0.82 (computed from 11 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association | taxpayer | 其他團體 | Anchor for the state scale's right end (the two major parties and the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn.); state axis +1.00 (computed from 10 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| California Labor Federation | labor | 勞工 | state axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| California Chamber of Commerce | business | 商界 | No Nov 2026 positions could be read; the org has no effect on any score. |
| ACLU of Northern California | civil-rights | 其他團體 | state axis not scored: fewer than 3 measures with a yes/no position where the anchors split |
| League of Women Voters of California | good-government | 其他團體 | state axis -0.71 (computed from 12 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |
| California Teachers Association | labor | 勞工 | state axis -0.60 (computed from 5 measures where the anchors split; +1 = always with the right anchors, -1 = always with the left anchors) |